Showing posts with label IGF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IGF. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

All aboard for IGF 2012

For many IGF 2012 participants, the fun started well before arriving in Baku.

There was the last minute change in hotels due to apparently unforeseen renovations. I have been told this was local host diplomatic language for "oops, we overbooked the hotel".

Only a fortnight or so before IGF, there were major changes to British Airways' entire schedule to Baku, causing people flying from Heathrow to either arrive in Baku extra early or miss the pre-events day.

There was also, of course, the multiplying invitation letters from the local host. However, invitation letters from two different Azerbaijani government departments and the confirmation letter from IGF was apparently not enough for some of the on-arrival visa officials, who demanded that one participant also present an invitation letter from the United Nations.

A taste of the local culture on flights to Baku

It took ten minutes per passenger to check in from Paris on Azerbaijan Airlines. Apparently this was due to the local office being closed on a Sunday. In reality, it was a way to get IGF attendees used to queuing.

On one flight, an Azerbaijani woman told Milton Mueller, "I want your seat". When he looked at her, incredulous, she repeated, "I want your seat". He said no. She asked again, apparently not having heard that Milton can explode when provoked, but Milton stuck to his guns and wouldn't budge.

On the same flight, another Azerbaijani woman poked a sleeping Bill Smith from Paypal, declaring "You swap". Bill, lacking Milton's fortitude, swapped seats.

On another flight to Baku, a fight at the back of the plane was averted by airline stewards. One very drunk local was singing too loudly and long for another local and angry words ensued. This was Emma Frost's (ISOC) introduction to Azerbaijani culture. On landing, the drunk man preferred sitting with the IGF attendees waiting for their visas rather than passing through Customs, and had to be coaxed through by airport staff.

A hint to Azerbaijan Airlines: you might want to edit out the part of your passenger safety video that actually shows a person bobbing up and down in the water with the plane floating/sinking in the background. It frightens small children and IGF attendees. Also, Jason Munyan from UNCTAD would like to know exactly how it is that passengers spontaneously gain massive amounts of weight when opening the emergency exits, as demonstrated in the exit row safety card.

First introduction to Baku fun buses

    Please note the man in fur hat in top right corner of photo. More about him below.

On my bus, we dropped a local wearing a Russian-style fur hat off at a bus stop on the way. Which was nice of the driver. We almost lost all our luggage under the cars behind us when the back door of the minibus flung open as we went uphill. Apparently I was the only one who noticed, and it took a while for the others to understand why I was insanely shouting "Stop! Stop! Stop" while lunging over the back seat to grab the handle of the bag closest to the open door. At one point, while the meet and greet staff were helping an attendee into her hotel, the driver took the opportunity to go AWOL for a bit. The IGF volunteers launch a mini manhunt to retrieved him.

It seems that on average, buses took three hours to go between the airport and last hotel, with many pitstops on the way to ask locals for the way to various hotels. IGF attendees on the bus asking how much longer the journey would be got used to the refrain "Ten minutes, not much further, we're almost there".

The upside of long and circuitous bus routes? We got to see more than Baku than we usually see of countries we attend conferences in.

"There will be a bus at 7:00 am this morning"

A hint to future IGF organizers: when deciding to provide bus services for IGF pre-event days in future, please make sure notification comes earlier than 2 am, only five hours before the bus is going to leave. A printed notice posted under delegates' doors in the wee hours of the morning guarantees your bus drivers will get the morning off.

And this was all before IGF officially began. More later on the food (or lack thereof), the headphones, the fragile walls, and a really packed IGF program.

Friday, April 27, 2012

Gender equality and Internet governance

The recent publication of the 2012 Internet Governance Forum (IGF) Multistakeholder Advisory Group (MAG) initially got me cranky to see that the RIRs are represented on the MAG by three middle-aged white men. Yes, one of those middle-aged white men is based in Dubai, and was born in the Middle East, and so speaks Arabic. Yes, another of those middle-aged white men is from South America and speaks both Portuguese and Spanish. And yes, the remaining middle-aged white man is there because he's representing an Asia Pacific organization. And speaks some Spanish, too, if I remember correctly. So the regional and linguistic representation boxes can be ticked.

But where are the women from RIRs? The one female representative from the RIRs, Cathy Handley, has been rotated off. Let's look at women on the MAG from elsewhere in the technical world. Emily Taylor, who was originally chosen as a representative of Nominet, has been rotated off. Nurani Nimpuno remains one of the technical community's representatives on the MAG. Constance Bommelaer, my colleague on the Commission on Science and Technology for Development Working Group (CSTDWG) on IGF, joins the MAG from ISOC. Overall, there are 23 women in the 56-member MAG for 2012. So there are still 10 more men on the MAG than women. So still not quite gender balance there. But not bad when you consider the following.

Gender balance in the Regional Internet Registries (RIRs)

First, a word of explanation. I am not picking on the RIRs because their gender balance is worse than any other one of the Internet technical organizations. It was simply easier for me to look at five RIR websites (plus the NRO one) than it was to look at around 200 ccTLD websites, 21 gTLD websites, or the wide number of IETF Working Groups. For all I know, gender balance is worse in those worlds. If I have the energy, I'll track those down later. Also, please note that I am not looking at cultural or linguistic diversity here. The RIRs, on the whole, do a pretty good job in that field.

There are five RIRs. The CEOs of all five are men. Four of the five Board Chairs are men. The Boards of ARIN, LACNIC, and RIPE are composed entirely of men. But look a little closer, and you'll find some women the RIRs:

AfriNIC

AfriNIC wins the gender balance race amongst RIRs, but even its figures are depressing. AfriNIC has a female Board Chair, Ndeye Maimouna Diop Diagne, and a female alternate Board member, Lillian Wambui Karanja. So two of its current 13 primary and alternate Board members are female. And one of its past 24 Board members was female.

One of AfriNIC's female staff has the title of manager, and there are two vacant manager positions, so there's a chance AfriNIC will get some more female management in the near future. Out of its current 22 staff, nine are women. But of those nine, only two work in the technical area (the other six in the technical area are men). The rest of the women work in traditionally "female" areas of communications and administration.

Update (Friday 4:24 pm): There is a second female manager at AfriNIC in the role of Registration Services Manager. The website just hasn't been updated to show it yet, although I suspect it will be updated shortly. The total number of female employees, however, doesn't change as an existing female technical staff member was recruited for the management position.

APNIC

APNIC comes second, being the only other RIR to have a woman on its Board, Wei Zhao. APNIC has also had another woman (also from CNNIC) on its Board (known as the Executive Council) in the past. So one out of eight current Board members is a woman, and one out of 22 past Board members has been a woman. It's actually worse than that if you consider a number of the past members served more than one term, meaning that only two women have been elected out of a total of around 40 places on the Board since the late 1990s.

There are two women on APNIC's 11-member Executive Team. But both in traditional "female" roles: human resources and an executive assistant. 29 of APNIC's 68 staff are women, seven of whom are in technical roles. The rest of the women, once again, work in those traditionally "female areas" of communications and administration. I'm including the female trainers within the broad area of communications, but if you want to consider them to be technical, it bumps up the female staff in technical positions to nine.

ARIN

ARIN has no women on its seven-member Board of Directors, and never has, but it does have three women on its Advisory Council (the body that advises the Board on policy matters).

There is one woman in ARIN's three-member executive team. ARIN currently has 50 staff, and two vacant positions. Of the current 50 staff, 20 are female. There are two names where I can't be sure of the gender, so possibly it's 22 female staff. Eight of the women work in technical areas. One other works in public affairs.

RIPE and RIPE NCC

Like ARIN, RIPE has never had a woman on its Board.

Nobody in its six-member senior management team is female. Out of its 137 staff, 51 are female. Of those, 10 are in what I'd consider to be technical positions. If you include the customer services women, it takes the technical total to 15. All the rest are, to be depressingly repetitive, in communications and administration roles. A number of the technical areas at RIPE NCC are completely male, including Research & Development, Global Information Infrastructure and the Database Group. There is one woman in the external relations area.

LACNIC

None of LACNIC's current Board members are women. LACNIC doesn't publish an easy to find list of their past Board members, but I think it's a reasonably safe to assume that past members haven't been female either. I wasn't able to find a staff list on LACNIC's website, so I can't analyze their staff composition either. But I'll give LACNIC the benefit of the doubt and assume that their male/female ratios are no worse than the other four RIRs.

NRO

The Number Resource Organization (NRO) is the coalition of the five RIRs and also performs the ICANN Address Supporting Organization (ASO) function. As such, the NRO Executive Council, which consists of the five RIR CEOs, is entirely male. And the 15-member NRO Number Council, which performs the function of the ASO Address Council (AC) has one female member, from the AfriNIC region. Developed regions of the world, you should be very embarrassed that it is a developing region of the world that is putting forward the single female representative on this international Number Council.

Gender balance in the IGF

Gender balance is one of the goals of IGF MAG composition, along with regional and stakeholder diversity. Likewise, gender balance is one of the items IGF workshop organizers are supposed to address in their list of workshop speakers. Women form just over two fifths of the current 2012 MAG. And a browse through past IGF workshops and main sessions shows that the majority have at least one female speaker. It's often not half male and half female, but at least women are on the panel. It could be far better though. Civil society is particularly adept at including women as representatives.

Comparing gender balance in RIRs and United Nations-related Internet governance areas

In the various moments of crisis over the past few years when it has looked like Internet governance might move into a government-only sphere, the technical community has been very vocal in insisting that Internet governance is at its best when it has multistakeholder input and governance. And the fact that the IGF MAG has almost as many women amongst its members as men shows that diversity is being given serious consideration. The CSTDWG on IGF also had a good number of female members, including three of the five technical and academic community representatives.

So compare the gender balance in Internet governance arenas at the international (UN-related) level with what's happening at the RIR level. Why so few women in key decision-making positions within the RIRs, both within the staff and within Boards? Why is there such a large gender imbalance both within decision-making roles and in technical positions? There are three issues I can see that contribute to this:

  • Women traditionally have not chosen technical careers. But this is changing. There are a lot of women who have IT qualifications. And until women can see that other women are able to succeed in the IT world without having to beat off unwanted attention from the stereotypically socially inept male geeks, amongst other things, young girls will remain less likely to choose IT as a career. But if girls can see that being a woman in IT is not only possible, but rewarding, there'll be a greater pool of female IT graduates to be employed by organizations and companies.
  • RIR staff appointments are made by RIR staff. Given so many of the senior RIR staff are male, it may not even enter their minds to think that it's important to encourage women in senior or technical roles. Even if it did, I suspect many of them would use the "But no qualified women applied for the position". To that, I say, "See above, about women in IT needing role models" and "Look harder, just like you look harder to find regionally diverse applicants".
  • RIR Boards are nominated and elected by RIR members, not RIR staff. It is possible that RIR members, who are usually ISPs, suffer from the same male-dominated senior management and technical staff issues as the RIRs, and therefore, once again, the thought of gender balance doesn't even enter their consciousness during the election process.

The Internet community often talk about the benefits of "bottom-up development" in Internet development. But here, it looks to me like RIRs and their communities need to follow the "top-down" example of international UN-related Internet governance bodies that make gender balance a priority.

I am not having a go at gender balance in the RIRs just because I'm a feminist with a mission (although I am that). There is an additional issue at stake here. If RIRs —and possibly other technical Internet organizations that I haven't looked at here— don't address the current gender imbalance, then they may find it very hard to sit on international Internet governance forums in future. The RIRs currently only have one woman on staff with external relations/public policy experience they could put forward for an international Internet governance forum: Cathy Handley. And she has already served her time on the IGF MAG. Who else can RIRs put forward right now apart from middle-aged white men? Perhaps one of the very few female members of their Boards if they were willing to fund them? If the RIRs don't work to fix this gender situation, they may find themselves on the outer as bodies like the MAG look for gender-balanced member compositions. Other Internet organizations, which may have similar gender imbalances, could also find themselves in the same position.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

UNGA Second Committee discusses Internet issues

On 26 October 2011, the UNGA Second Committee discussed three documents of interest to the Internet community as part of agenda item 16, Information and communication technologies for development:
  • A/66/77-E/2011/103 Report of the Secretary-General on enhanced cooperation on public policy issues pertaining to the Internet
  • A/66/67-E/2011/79 Report of the Working Group on Improvements to the Internet Governance Forum
  • A/66/64-E/2011/77 Report of the Secretary-General on progress made in the implementation of and follow-up to the outcomes of the World Summit on the Information Society at the regional and international levels

First, a little bit of context

The Second Committee's discussion was only days before the Working Group on Improvements to the Internet Governance Forum (CSTD WG) convenes for its third meeting in Geneva, 31 October - 2 November 2011). (As a member of the CSTD WG, I'll be blogging about its activities next week, so stay tuned.)

The Committe's discussion on enhanced cooperation comes in the wake of IBSA work on Internet governance in September and earlier this month. Following an IBSA Seminar on Global Internet Governance, 1-2 September 2011, IBSA issued a set of draft recommendations on Internet governance, in which they called for a new UN body to house the Internet governance enhanced cooperation process.

The draft recommendations resulted in a flurry of discussion in the Internet governance community:

Following the large amount of time spent on discussing the IBSA proposal at IGF, the language used by IBSA about Internet governance in its October Tshwane Declaration (paragraphs 52-55) was significantly toned down, but still was the cause of much discussion in the Internet community.

The Second Committee's discussion on World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS) follow-up took place after recent decisions by the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) 2011 Council to take the lead within UNGIS on a multistakeholder WSIS+10 process, but to keep its own newly renamed Working Group on International Internet-related Public Policy Issues open to Member States only.

    Note: While all workings of the Working Group on International Internet-related Public Policy Issues will remain closed to non-Member States, there is the opportunity for other Internet stakeholders to submit input as part of "open consultations" called by the WG.

Discussions at Second Committee on 26 October 2011

Below are some of the more interesting extracts from the long UN press release, with some initial reactions from me:

1. Role of UN in Internet governance
    "HAIYAN QIAN, Director, Division for Public Administration and Development Management, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, said that five years after the World Summit on Information Society, there was no common perspective on how to achieve enhanced cooperation on Internet-related international public policy issues. However, cooperation would be helpful on a wide range of key policy issues, including cybercrime, privacy and capacity-building, she said, adding that, although opinions differed on the most appropriate mechanisms, there was agreement on shared principles. While authority over Internet-related public policy issues was the sovereign right of States, management of the Internet should continue to follow a multi-stakeholder approach, she said, adding that consultations had reaffirmed the facilitating role of the United Nations in the relevant policymaking."

    My thoughts: It's encouraging to see DESA referring to the UN's role as playing a "facilitating", rather than authoritative, role in Internet governance-related public policy issues. This is in the spirit of the multistakeholder approach to Internet governance agreed to at WSIS.


2. Information technology and the Millennium Development Goals (MDG) deadline

    "YUSRA KHAN (Indonesia), speaking on behalf of the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN) and associating himself with the Group of 77 and China, said information and communications technology was a key driver of economic and social transformation. With barely four years left to meet the Millennium Development Goals, it was important to harness effectively its full potential as a strategic tool to help in meeting development goals."

    My thoughts: Will the looming 2015 MDG deadline, CSTD WG deliberations on how to better help the IGF better accomplish development goals, plus upcoming meetings like the ITU 2012 World Conference on International Telecommunications (WCIT) and 2013 World Telecommunication/ICT Policy Forum (WTPF) refocus Internet governance discussions in a more strongly developmental direction? The increasingly crowded calender of Internet governance related international events, while aiming to help progress issues, can paradoxically hinder progress. This is because no stakeholder group, whether they be government, civil society, business or technical, have the resources to track all activities at the exploding number of Internet governance related forums. When this happens, it's very possible that balls get dropped. Yes, one of the suggested improvements for IGF being discussed at the CSTD WG is having IGF be the lynchpin for connecting and sharing various Internet governance discussions, for the IGF Secretariat to attend other Internet governance meetings and disseminate IGF materials to all relevant parties. But to achieve this, the IGF is going to have to find a lot more funding in a world where the UN has across-the-board budget cuts, and other stakeholder groups are similarly financially stretched across competing, worthy projects.


3. The future of IGF
    "FÁBIO FARIAS ( Brazil), associating himself with the Group of 77 and China, [...] Calling for more investment in broadband infrastructure, he said that in light of the Internet’s standing as a global facility, according to the World Summit, its governance should be multilateral, transparent and democratic, with the full involvement of all Governments, the private sector, civil society and international organizations. The Internet Governance Forum should continue to focus on policy dialogue, on Internet governance and on creating mechanisms for greater participation by representatives of different stakeholders from developing countries, he said. It should also produce clear outputs of its discussions in order to fulfil the goal of contributing to the shaping of policies on the various actors involved in Internet governance."

    My thoughts: I'm not sure about the use of "multilateral", given, within the same sentence, Brazil talks about involving stakeholders outside government as well. Brazil has been consistently supporting the need for more clear outputs in the CSTD WG, so no surprises here. Also no surprises that the UK and Sweden stated their support for leveraging the multistakeholder IGF for enhancing Internet development. For the UK and Sweden's statements, see the very bottom of the UN press release.


4. The call for a UN Committee on enhanced cooperation
    "DUSHYANT SINGH (India) proposed the establishment of a new institutional mechanism within the United Nations for global Internet-related policies, to be called the United Nations Committee for Internet-Related Policies. The goal of such a mechanism would not be to control the Internet, but to ensure that the Internet was governed in an open, democratic, inclusive and participatory manner. The proposed committee would take on the task of developing international public policies to ensure coordination and coherence in cross-cutting Internet-related global issues, and addressing Internet-related developmental issues, among others. He said that his multi-ethnic, multicultural country, as a democratic society with an open economy and an abiding culture of pluralism, emphasized the importance of strengthening the Internet as a vehicle for openness, democracy, freedom of expression, human rights, diversity, inclusiveness and socio-economic growth. The governance of such an unprecedented global medium that embodied those values should be similarly inclusive, democratic, participatory, multilateral and transparent in nature, he said, emphasizing that India attached great importance to the preservation of the Internet as an unrestricted, open, and free global medium that flourished through private innovation and individual creativity. In order create the proposed committee, India called for the establishment of a working group to draw up the detailed terms, under the auspices of the Commission on Science and Technology for Development."

    My thoughts: So of the IBSA countries, neither Brazil nor South Africa mentioned the enhanced cooperation body that caused so much consternation after their draft recommendations in September this year. But India still supports it. Being totally selfish, I'm hoping this proposal for yet another CSTD WG doesn't derail the CSTD WG on IGF improvements discussion next week. I also wonder how India's proposal for this new committee interacts with ITU's work on Internet public policy issues through its own Working Group on International Internet-related Public Policy Issues and its discussions on Internet policy at WCIT and WTPF. The last thing any of us need is yet another body that duplicates (even partially) the work of another existing Internet governance body or forum.


5. Critical Internet resources
    "XIE XIAOWU (China), endorsing the statement made on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, [...] He stressed that States had the sovereign right to make decisions on any Internet-related public policy issues, adding that though the United Nations should play an active role in Internet governance, the principles of multilateralism, democracy, and transparency, should be respected. Efforts should also be made to include developing countries on an equal footing in the management of key Internet resources, he said, emphasizing that every State and individual was entitled to an information society that benefitted all citizens."

    My thoughts: It wouldn't be an Internet governance discussion without someone referring to ICANN/IANA being based on US government contract. China's 2010 Internet white paper states that it "maintains that all countries have equal rights in participating in the administration of the fundamental international resources of the Internet, and a multilateral and transparent allocation system should be established on the basis of the current management mode, so as to allocate those resources in a rational way and to promote the balanced development of the global Internet industry." So the statement made by China at the Second Committee is merely a reaffirmation of its stance.


Where to from here?

The deadline for draft resolutions on item 16, Information and communication technologies for development, is 28 October 2011. Watch this space...